preprint open access

Consistency Is Not Correctness: What Internal Contradiction Detection Certifies, Why the Entailment Is Disjunctive, and Which Decisions It Leaves Unlicensed

Abstract

Life of Research

(c) 2026 Pranay Mahendrakar. Licensed under CC BY 4.0.

Contradiction detection occupies an unusual position among proposals for making a language model check itself. Comparing two of a model's own outputs appears to need no external oracle, which makes it look like the one exception to the observation that working hallucination detectors sit outside the model. This paper argues that the appearance is produced by running two different inferences under one word. Inconsistency supports a deductive inference: if two outputs contradict each other, at least one of them is false, and this follows from logic alone without any appeal to the world. Consistency supports only an inductive one: agreement is evidence of correctness to the extent that the model's errors are unstable under whatever perturbation produced the second output, an assumption that the sampling-based detectors state explicitly and that the strongest published instance of the family declines to extend to systematic error. The two inferences have opposite properties. The deductive one is sound and disjunctive, identifying that something is wrong without identifying which output is wrong, and so licenses withholding but not repair. The inductive one names a specific output to accept, and fails in the cases that matter most, because an error shared by both compared outputs survives the comparison intact. The paper traces the consequences: that breaking the disjunction requires an adjudicator whose errors are not those of the generator, that every published route to one is external in the relevant sense even when it runs on the same weights, and that a consistency rate is a measurement of distributional stability under a named perturbation rather than a reliability figure. Making consistency an optimization target inverts its diagnostic value, which two recent results on label-free training report directly. What is not known is stated flatly, and six measurements are specified.

Pranay Mahendrakar, AI specialist

About the author

Pranay Mahendrakar is an ai specialist and large language model engineer based in Bengaluru, India. He builds production artificial intelligence systems and publishes open-access research on how those systems fail. See all 161 papers by Pranay Mahendrakar, or his ORCID record.

Questions about this paper

Who wrote "Consistency Is Not Correctness"?

Pranay Mahendrakar wrote "Consistency Is Not Correctness: What Internal Contradiction Detection Certifies, Why the Entailment Is Disjunctive, and Which Decisions It Leaves Unlicensed", published 7 Sep 2026. Pranay Mahendrakar is an Indian AI specialist and LLM engineer based in Bengaluru, India. He is the Managing Director of SonyTech, Nodal Coordinator at IIRS-ISRO, and an instructor at Tutorials Point. His work covers large language models, natural language processing, computer vision and retrieval-augmented generation. He publishes open-access research papers and is the author of three books: Just AI With Pranay, Multiverse of AI and It's Me LLM.

Is "Consistency Is Not Correctness" free to read?

Yes. "Consistency Is Not Correctness" by Pranay Mahendrakar is open access under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence, with the full PDF available from Zenodo at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22559866. There is no paywall and no account required.

How do I cite "Consistency Is Not Correctness"?

Cite the DOI: Mahendrakar, P. (2026). Consistency Is Not Correctness: What Internal Contradiction Detection Certifies, Why the Entailment Is Disjunctive, and Which Decisions It Leaves Unlicensed. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22559866 A BibTeX entry is provided on this page.

Related research by Pranay Mahendrakar

← All papers by Pranay Mahendrakar